STATEMENT
OF
JOHN M. GARCIA, CABINET SECRETARY
NEW MEXICO DEPARTMENT OF VETERANS’ SERVICES
OVERSIGHT HEARING
ON
DISABILITY COMPENSATION CLAIMS DECISIONS
BEFORE THE
SUBCOMMITTEE ON DISABILITY ASSISTANCE
AND MEMORIAL AFFAIRS
OCTOBER 20, 2005
Mr. Chairman and Distinguished Members of
the Committee, on behalf of the Veterans of the great State of New
Mexico and our Governor, Bill Richardson, I am honored to have this
opportunity to testify this morning and to present my views regarding
variances in disability compensation claim decisions made by the VA
regional offices and the factors that are affecting the review process.
New Mexico, unlike any other State in the Union, has a 400-year rich
military legacy. Many New Mexico natives such as myself can proudly
trace our ancestry back eleven generations, to the early citizen
soldiers that first arrived in the Southwest Region of our Country. Many
citizens from the great State of New Mexico have served our Nation with
dignity and honor from the Civil War to the fields of France during
World War I to the battlefields of World War II and Korea, to the steamy
jungles of Vietnam, to the desert sands of the Gulf War, and to the War
in Iraq, New Mexicans have served with distinction. Our military legacy
is made up of our infamous Navajo Code Talkers and our Bataan Death
March Veterans whose place in American history has been firmly planted,
and their story remains an incredible testimony to the courage and
sacrifice of these men. Our New Mexico Vietnam Veterans were No. 1 in
draftee percentage per capita, and our State was the third highest in
casualty rate during the Vietnam War and we were the first into Iraq
with our stealth fighters out of Holloman Air Force Base. New Mexico’s
Veterans have a rich legacy of honor and pride of service to their
Country.
In the year 2003, Governor Bill Richardson elevated what was once the
Veterans’ Services Commission to what is now the New Mexico Department
of Veterans’ Services, a cabinet level Agency, in order to better serve
our Veterans. In partnership with the Veterans Administration Regional
Office, the Veterans Administration Hospital, the Veteran Centers, and
the Veteran Services Organizations, our Agency has created a New Mexico
Veteran Administrative team providing an array of resources for outreach
and benefits for our New Mexico Veterans. As a result, New Mexico is
ranked among the top five (5) states assisting Veterans in receiving
their disability, comp and pen benefits.
The Veterans Administration spent approximately $6.3million in New
Mexico in 2003 to serve more than 185,000 Veterans who live in our
State. Last year, approximately 59,000 Veterans received health care,
and 31,000 Veterans and their survivors received disability compensation
or pension payments from the Veterans’ Administration in New Mexico per
capita. More than 4,500 Veterans, reservists, and survivors used GI Bill
payments for their education, and twenty four thousand owned homes with
active VA home loan guarantees, and over 1,600 were interred in Ft.
Bayard and Santa Fe National Cemeteries. Since 2003, we have seen a
substantial increase in benefits and services to our New Mexico
Veterans.
Per the Department of Veterans Affairs’ Office of Inspector General (VAIG)
recommendation, the Veterans’ Benefits Administration will begin a
review of an additional 72,000 claims that were awarded disability
compensation for PTSD at the 100% scheduler rate or 100% based on
individual unemployability.
Of the original sampling of 2,100 claims, there were three hundred cases
from the State of New Mexico which were identified for further review,
and letters were sent to each of them. The letters that were sent were
threatening and strongly implied a loss of benefits at two levels: 1.
The letter implied the Veteran would lose benefits if he did not comply,
and 2. The letter implied that Veterans would lose benefits if they were
not under current treatment.
This policy of “retroactive inspection” has been received by the ENTIRE
Veteran community as an assault on every Veteran, not just those for
review. It is clearly perceived by our Veteran community as an
“attitude” and not a policy.
How serious is this problem? On October 8th, a Vietnam Veteran from New
Mexico committed suicide. He was a 100% service connected PTSD/Unemployability
combat Veteran in receipt of a Purple Heart. HE WAS NOT ONE OF THE NEW
MEXICO VETERANS SELECTED FOR REVIEW, but it was clear to those who found
him that the issue was on his mind because of information about the
retroactive inspection was found at his side next to his Purple Heart
Medal. He is clearly a casualty of this review.
Why? Because an attack on one Veteran is an attack on all of them. Let
me make this clear. This review policy is perceived as an attitude, an
attack, and a personal assault on the Honorable service of all Veterans.
Service-connected compensation should be considered a “Cost of War,” as
should our commitment to taking care of our disabled veterans’ health
care.
I recently returned from National Association of State Directors of
Veterans Affairs Conference. During that Conference, the VA central
office publicly stated that the letters sent to New Mexico Veterans were
“horrible and a travesty” and a public apology was rendered. At this
same Conference, we were told Veterans would have “to get in line” for
their health care budget along with all the other Federal agencies. This
means that we have no priority or guarantee of health care.
Are we truly seeing an “attitude”? As Secretary of the New Mexico
Department of Veterans’ Services, it certainly appears this way.
What can we do?
1. We can drop the retroactive inspections.
2. We can adequately fund future health care for our disabled veterans.
3. We can promise our young men and women, in writing, before we send
them in harm’s way that we can take care of them and their health needs
for their lifetime.
On October 7, 2005, I attended a burial ceremony for eight (8) soldiers
who died in Vietnam in 1968, and whose remains were recovered and
interred at Arlington National Cemetery. One of the soldiers interred
was from Albuquerque, New Mexico. Upon my return home, I also received a
letter that was forwarded to our Governor requesting assistance for her
Vietnam Veteran husband, and at this time I would like to read that
letter to you. The letter is dated October 7, 2005:
Dear Mr. Governor:
I am a 3rd generation native of New Mexico. I am proud of being a part
of a grand State. I am especially proud of the treatment our war
veterans have received from State government. My father was a veteran of
WWII, and spent some time in Korea in 1954-1955. I would like you to
know that my husband and I appreciate everything this State stands for
regarding our veterans.
Recently, my husband received a letter from the Department of Veterans
Affairs. This letter indicated that he was under for determination of
his benefits. He was given 60 days to respond. He was, in effect, asked
to prove all over again what he had spent the last 36 years trying to
prove. At this time, he is receiving 100% benefits for PTSD.
As a result of this letter, I have spent the last three nights watching
him walk the floor, scared his benefits are going to be cut off. He
turned in all his paperwork as asked on Monday, October 3rd, and was
told by the representative at the DVA Regional Office in Albuquerque,
New Mexico that he would receive a call from that office by Monday
afternoon. He is still waiting for that call! Many attempts to contact
that office have been futile. The young lady who was to call him back
“this afternoon” is either not in, away from her desk, or unavailable. I
find this unacceptable.
This morning, I went to work, and when I called my husband to inform him
that I was safe at work, he told me he was going to “fix everything.” I
left work, and when I returned home, he had called his brother to pick
the two guns that he owns. I immediately contacted the VA hospital, and
spoke to Dr. Mike Burger. He calmed my husband down, and promised that
he would look into the VA Administration, and gather information. Then
he would call us back.
I guess what I want you to know is that there are a large number of
Veterans in New Mexico who have received this same letter. They and
their families are going through much the same thing that my family is.
This has affected me, our children, and our grandchildren.
Something needs to be done to stop this madness. Our Veterans are
feeling that they are worthless, and are being called liars. How many
veterans will succeed, where my husband did not this morning? This is
very painful, and I can’t stress enough how important these Veterans are
to us. This is my life, my husband’s life, and our family’s life.
Please understand that there may be others who are feeling the same if
not worse. If this continues, there are going to be more dead soldiers
and they won’t even have to leave the States.
Thank you for all you have done for the Veterans.
Mrs. Lane De Priest
Mr. Chairman and Distinguished Members of the Committee, I respect the
important work that you and Members of this Committee are doing to
improve the support to our Veterans who answered the call to serve our
Country. The New Mexico Department of Veterans’ Services is dedicated to
providing outreach services and benefits to our Veterans. On behalf of
the Veterans of the State of New Mexico and the over 26 million Veterans
in this Country, I thank you for allowing me to express my concerns.
This concludes my statement, and I am happy to respond to any questions.
Mr. John M. Garcia, Cabinet Secretary
New Mexico Department of Veterans’ Services
P. O. Box 2324
Santa Fe, NM 87504-2324
Phone: (505) 827-6312
Email: johnm.garcia@state.nm.us
|