TESTIMONY
Of
THE HONORABLE THOMAS F. HALL
ASSISTANT SECRETARY OF DEFENSE
RESERVE AFFAIRS
BEFORE THE
HOUSE COMMITTEE ON VETERANS AFFAIRS
10:30 AM
MARCH 15, 2006
ROOM 334
CANNON HOUSE OFFICE BUILDING
Honorable Thomas F. Hall
Assistant Secretary of Defense for Reserve Affairs
________________________________________
Secretary Thomas F. Hall, a native of
Barnsdall, Oklahoma, was sworn in as the fourth Assistant Secretary of
Defense for Reserve Affairs on October 9, 2002. A Presidential appointee
confirmed by the Senate, he serves as the principal staff assistant to
the Secretary of Defense on all matters involving the 1.2 million
members of the Reserve components of the United States Armed Forces. He
is responsible for overall supervision of Reserve component affairs of
the Department of Defense.
Secretary Hall is a retired two-star Rear Admiral having served almost
34 years of continuous active duty in the United States Navy. He is a
distinguished and decorated Naval Aviator, who served a combat tour in
Vietnam. He has performed in numerous high level staff, command, and
NATO positions during his career. He commanded Patrol Squadron EIGHT,
Naval Air Station Bermuda, and the Iceland Defense Force. His final
military assignment was as the Commander/Director/Chief of Naval
Reserve. His military awards include the Distinguished Service Medal,
Defense Superior Service Medal, Legion of Merit, Air Medal, and various
other personal and unit decorations. He was awarded the Order of the
Falcon, with Commander’s Cross, by the President of Iceland in
recognition of his accomplishments and service as Commander Iceland
Defense Force. In 2000, he was given the International Partnership Award
for his service to the United States and Iceland. He has been inducted
into the Oklahoma Military Hall of Fame. In 2003, he was given the
National Service Award for Leadership by the Federal Law Enforcement
Foundation. In 2004, he was given the National Citizenship Award by the
Military Chaplains Association of the United States. In 2005, he was
given the Admiral Jackson award by the Reserve Officers Association.
Secretary Hall attended Oklahoma State University for one year before
entering the United States Naval Academy in Annapolis, Maryland. In
1963, he graduated from the Academy with a bachelor’s degree in
Engineering and was named as one of the top 25 leaders in his class,
having commanded both the top Battalion and Company. He was, also,
awarded the Brigade Intramural Sports Trophy. In 1971, he received a
master’s degree in Public Personnel Management from George Washington
University. He graduated with highest distinction from the Naval War
College; with distinction, from the National War College; and from the
National Security Course at Harvard University. He was selected as a
Fellow and served on the Chief of Naval Operations Strategic Studies
Group.
Secretary Hall has served on the Boards of Directors of numerous
nonprofit organizations that are supporting the needs of our veterans
and citizens in general. Prior to returning to government service,
Secretary Hall served as the Executive Director of the Naval Reserve
Association for six years. The Naval Reserve Association is a 501 (c)
(3) nonprofit veterans’ organization that represents over 23,000 Naval
Reserve officers, members, and their families.
Secretary Hall is married to the former Barbara Norman of Jacksonville,
Florida. They have one son, Thomas David Hall.
Mr. Chairman and members of the Committee, thank you for giving me the
opportunity to come before you this morning discuss the Montgomery GI
Bill for the Selected Reserve (MGIB-SR) and the Education Assistance
Program for Reserve Component Members Supporting Contingency Operations
and Certain Other Operations, which we and the Department of Veterans
Affairs refer to as the Reserve Education Assistance Program (REAP).
The MGIB-SR was established to encourage membership in units of the
Selected Reserve. It has proven to be a very attractive recruiting tool,
and its effectiveness as a retention tool is certainly equally important
to the Reserve components. In combination with Kicker payments, which
allow us to target specific, critical wartime skill shortages with
additional benefit payments of up to $350 per month, the MGIB-SR is a
very well known program among Reserve component members and has worked
well in helping the components maintain achieve their strength
requirements. The fact that a member must continue to serve in the
Reserves to maintain eligibility has greatly assisted the Reserve
components as a whole in maintaining consistently high retention rates
over the years and has increased the education level of our Reserve
force. The continued support of Congress for the MGIB-SR has provided
the Department with a very powerful incentive to join the National Guard
or Reserve as a member of the Selected Reserve and to continue
membership beyond the initial service obligation period. Between 1984
and 2005, over 1,490,000 Selected Reserve members gained eligibility for
MGIB-SR entitlement, and over 585,000, or 39 percent, have applied for
educational assistance.
Thirty percent of Reserve component members who are currently eligible
for the MGIB-SR benefits have applied for the benefit. This represents a
two percentage point increase in the past two years. In Fiscal Year
2005, almost $195,000,000 in benefits were paid to 87,161 Selected
Reserve members who were participating in the MGIB-SR program that year.
The program continues to fulfill its intended purposes. Four of the six
Department of Defense Reserve components are meeting or exceeding their
recruiting goals for 2006 in a very challenging recruiting environment,
and attrition in all of the Reserve components is within acceptable
limits and is very consistent with historic levels.
Improvements over the years have made the MGIB-SR even more attractive
and useful. Thanks to Congressional action expanding the permissible use
of benefits, over 12,000 Selected Reserve members now use MGIB-SR
benefits in pursuit of masters and doctoral degrees. In the National
Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2006, Congress provided
authority to use MGIB-SR benefits up to $2,000 for licensing and
certification tests. This program enhancement provides a strong
encouragement for our Selected Reserve members to obtain certification
in civilian skills that are of great value to the military, and it
assists our military members in obtaining civilian certification in
skills learned and developed in the military to enhance their civilian
employment opportunities.
We have not identified any significant shortcomings in the structure and
utility of the MGIB-SR. In future studies, we wish to assess whether
this benefit should be better linked to chapter 30 MGIB. Although we
have met our total recruiting and retention needs for most years since
the MGIB-SR was enacted, we believe we will continue to face challenges
in our recruiting efforts in the foreseeable future.
In the Ronald W. Reagan National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal
Year 2005, Congress, at the President’s request provided the REAP
program, which recognizes the significant active service participation
of Reserve component members in the Global War on Terror. This authority
supports the Department’s efforts to focus new benefits and entitlements
on those who are bearing the burden of mobilization. We sincerely
appreciate Congress’s support for the technical changes we requested
last year to improve the program. At this time, we have not identified
any further changes we need to make to this program.
The REAP program has been implemented and is working quite well. Under a
memorandum of understanding between the Departments of Defense, Veterans
Affairs and Homeland Security, payments under the program began in early
December 2005. As of February 24, 2006, the Department of Veterans
Affairs has received 13,929 benefit claims, and paid 959 claims, for a
total disbursement of over $1.54 million. Ongoing changes to electronic
data systems will greatly improve the application process and accelerate
the benefit delivery procedures.
Certainly almost any program can be improved, and we are interested, as
this Committee is, in ensuring that the MGIB, and all voluntary
education assistance programs, are robust and adequate to ensure that
the Department of Defense and the United States Coast Guard can meet
their human resource needs in the future. A joint Department of Defense
and Department of Veterans Affairs working group is currently examining
the possibility of a Total Force education benefit that would draw from
the best attributes of the two MGIB programs and the REAP. We are
actively participating in that forum, and we appreciate discussions that
examine overall program performance and identify opportunities for
improvement in education assistance programs that meet the needs of
veterans and Reserve component members. As we work collaboratively and
deliberately with the goal of program improvement, we need to stress
that the veteran and reserve programs were designed for and serve
different purposes. Both reserve benefits – the MGIB-SR program and the
REAP – were designed as retention tools, to keep members serving in the
Guard or Reserve; a benefit for continued service just like bonuses. The
veteran benefit, although it can be used by someone still serving, was
designed to assist members in transitioning to civilian life following
service. As we examine the potential for a Total Force GI bill, we want
to be certain that such a program would encourage continued reserve
membership as effectively as the current programs. Anything that could
be viewed as changing the basic premise of the MGIB-SR and the REAP
should be considered very carefully.
The MGIB-SR continues to be one of the most popular and effective
Reserve component programs. Whether used alone, or in combination with
other voluntary educational programs, the MGIB-SR is an important
element in providing educational benefits to the men and women of the
Reserve components and in meeting our manpower requirements. We
recognize the importance that continuing education plays in the lives of
our Guard and Reserve members.
I am pleased to report that 787 Reserve component members have achieved
eligibility to enroll in the active duty MGIB as a result of being
mobilized in support of the Global War on Terror and completing 24
continuous months of service, and they have made the $1,200 contribution
required for the basic benefit. In addition, 593 Reserve component
members who already held eligibility for active duty MGIB benefits have
opted to increase their benefit by making an additional contribution.
Combined with any MGIB-SR entitlement they may have, this active duty
MGIB benefit may give these members a total of 48 academic months of
education benefits.
However, with nearly 485,000 Guard and Reserve members mobilized since
9/11, a very small percentage of the force has met the 24 continuous
month requirement to qualify for the active duty MGIB benefit.
Again, we believe that the Montgomery GI Bills under both chapter 1606
of title 10, United States Code, and chapter 30 of title 38, United
States Code, continue to serve us well. Combined with the REAP under
chapter 1607, they encourage service and permit us to recognize the
increased contribution of our Reserve component members to worldwide
military operations. We look forward to working with this committee and
the Armed Services Committees of the House and the Senate to ensure that
these programs remain robust. I would again like to thank the Committee
for all you have done for our servicemembers. The Department of Defense
appreciates this opportunity to discuss these important matters with
you.
|