Prepared Statement Of
Mr. Craig W. Duehring
Principal Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense
for
Reserve Affairs
June 29, 2005
Craig W. Duehring
Principal Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for Reserve Affairs
________________________________________
Mr. Duehring is the Principal Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for
Reserve Affairs. He also performs the duties of acting Assistant
Secretary of Defense for Reserve Affairs in the absence of the ASD/RA.
He was selected effective July 23, 2001.
As the Principal Deputy, Mr. Duehring serves as the senior deputy to the
Assistant Secretary of Defense for Reserve Affairs in policy development
and overall supervision of the National Guard and Reserve forces of the
armed forces of the United States. He is the chief staff advisor to the
assistant secretary for all functional areas and responsibilities
assigned to the office.
Previously, Duehring served on the Bush-Cheney Transition Team and the
Department of Defense Transition Team. He was the executive director of
the Patrick Henry Center for Individual Liberty, a non-profit 501 (c)(3)
educational and charitable foundation located in Fairfax, Virginia.
Duehring was the endorsed Republican candidate for the Minnesota 2nd
Congressional District in 1998. He is a 28-year military veteran,
retiring as a colonel in the U.S. Air Force in February 1996. His final
military assignment was as the U.S. Air Attaché to the Republic of
Indonesia.
He is a decorated combat pilot, completing over 800 missions during the
Vietnam War as a Forward Air Controller. Duehring has flown more than a
dozen types of aircraft, amassing over 1,200 hours in the A-10
Thunderbolt II. His military awards and decorations include the Silver
Star, the Defense Superior Service Medal, two Distinguished Flying
Crosses, three Meritorious Service Medals, 27 Air Medals, two Air Force
Commendation Medals, the Vietnamese Cross of Gallantry (individual
award),and the Vietnamese Staff Service Honor Medal (1st Class).
Duehring is also a recipient of the Air Force’s highest individual award
for leadership in the senior officer category, the Lance P. Sijan
(SIGH-john) Award.
Duehring holds a bachelor of science in History and Sociology from
Minnesota State University at Mankato, and a master of science in
Counseling and Guidance from Troy State University.
He is a native of Mankato, Minnesota.
Introduction
Mr. Chairman and members of the Subcommittee, thank you for the
opportunity to speak before you today. It is my privilege to discuss the
Transition Assistance Program (TAP) and the Disabled Transition
Assistance Program (DTAP).
Congress, and in particular this subcommittee, deserves sincere thanks
for its continued support of our efforts to ease the transition of our
separating and retiring Service members, as well as those being released
from active duty from the Guard and Reserves. Your interest and
assistance on this matter, both individually and as an institution, are
very much appreciated.
First let me restate our commitment to our separating Service members.
It is more important today than ever that we take care of our military
personnel and their families as they enter and leave active duty. The
Department and the Military Services, in partnership with the
Departments of Labor and Veterans Affairs, provide transition services;
“Because it’s right; because it’s smart.”
I know that you share our pride in the professionalism and dedication of
today’s Armed Forces. Whenever this Nation has gone to war, we demanded
the best from those who serve. Today is no different. The Global War on
Terrorism has forced us into a war, not of our own making or choosing.
To meet this challenge, and to defeat the enemy, we are calling upon the
total military forces of this Nation -- Soldiers, Sailors, Airmen,
Marines, members of the Coast Guard, the Guard and Reserves, and their
families. And, as in the past, we ask for commitment and a great deal of
sacrifice from our Service members and their families.
We recognize that we must reciprocate by providing benefits and services
to our military personnel who have earned them by virtue of their
valiant and heroic service. One major way to honor their service is by
caring for them and their families as they leave active duty.
Transition Assistance Program
Mr. Chairman and members of the Subcommittee let me begin by laying a
foundation of the Transition Assistance Program with two important
points. First, TAP was developed primarily for Active Component Service
members and their spouses. Second, I think it is important, at least for
the duration of this hearing, that we all operate with the same
understanding of what is included in TAP from a DoD perspective. Within
DoD, and I believe my distinguished colleagues from DOL and VA will back
me up on this – TAP is one program consisting of four basic components.
The four components are:
1. Preseparation Counseling – DoD has responsibility
2. DOL TAP Employment Workshops – DOL has responsibility
3. VA Benefits Briefings – VA has responsibility
4. Disabled Transition Assistance Program (DTAP) – VA has responsibility
Each agency is responsible for their component of the program, with DoD
serving as the coordinating agency for the entire program.
The reason this second point is germane is, as all too often, visitors
to our military installations reviewing the transition program conclude
that the Military Services have different transition programs and none
are the same. The confusion comes from differences in how each Service
delivers TAP. The Military Departments use diverse methods of program
delivery, but they all provide the same program – preseparation
counseling, DOL TAP Employment Workshops, VA Benefits Briefings and DTAP.
How a Military Service packages and delivers the four components of the
program can vary by Service, installation, and in the overseas areas of
operation.
Let me also note that the Military Services provide more than
preseparation counseling. Each of the Services has established permanent
employment assistance centers (part of TAP) as required by public law.
These centers provide follow-on employment assistance once the Service
member has attended a DOL TAP Employment Workshop. Some of the follow-on
assistance provided includes the actual preparation of a resume and
cover letter, use of the internet to search various Job Data Banks, and
most important, one-on-one counseling and review of resumes by highly
qualified counselors.
With this basic understanding in mind, let me turn my attention to why
we are here today.
One of the greatest successes in the Department of Defense is the
Transition Assistance Program, commonly referred to as TAP. Simply
stated, TAP’s mission is to prepare Service members and their families
for a successful transition to civilian life. Through this program, the
Department provides an extensive array of services and benefits designed
to equip separating Service members with basic skills, tools, and the
self-confidence necessary to prepare them to join the civilian workforce
of the 21st Century. As you are well aware, not all separating Service
members leave the military and go directly into the workforce. Some
decide to continue their education. Others may enter business for
themselves, or obtain professional credentials that enable them to meet
the various licensing and certification requirements of their chosen
profession. And some realize, while going through the transition
process, they are not really prepared to leave the military and choose
to reenlist. Whatever their decision may be, our goal is to provide them
with as many options as possible, so they can make an informed decision
about their future.
Some TAP Accomplishments
Let me highlight a few of our TAP accomplishments in recent years.
• Assisted the Department of Labor in developing the Military Resume
Writer, which is an automated tool for use by separating military
personnel. It allows them to put their resume on-line through a DOL
associate web site to America’s Job Bank called DoD Job Search. This
associate Web site directs separating Service members and veterans to
the same Web site as employers who are interested in hiring separating
Service members and veterans.
• Assisted the Department of Labor in the first phase of their
assumption of responsibility for conducting TAP Employment Workshops
overseas. The Department will continue to assist DOL in any way possible
as they move forward, in the near future, to provide TAP Employment
Workshops at all overseas locations.
• DoD, DOL, and VA provided TAP services and briefings on board the USS
Constellation, the USS Enterprise, and the USS George Washington as they
returned to their homeports after deployments.
• The Army is going to open an Army Career and Alumni Program (ACAP)
Center at the Walter Reed Army Medical Center in the near future.
• The Navy plans to open a fully operational Transition Assistance
Management Program (TAMP) Office at the National Naval Medical Center –
Bethesda.
Guard and Reserve
As you know, the Department and the Military Services provide
outstanding transition assistance to the Active Component. The Guard and
Reserve present special challenges for transition assistance based upon
the almost immediate deactivation and return to their family and local
communities. Upon demobilization, Guard and Reserve members, like their
counterparts in the Active Component, receive the mandatory
preseparation counseling. The preseparation counseling briefing explains
the transition benefits and services to which they are entitled as a
result of their service. Topics covered include employment, relocation,
education and training, health and insurance, finances, and disabled
veterans benefits.
With the support of our partners from the Departments of Labor and
Veterans Affairs, every effort is made to ensure Reserve Component
Service members receive a Uniformed Services Employment and Reemployment
Rights Act (USERRA)Briefing as well as a VA Benefits Briefing prior to
their release from active duty and during the demobilization process.
These are in addition to the mandated preseparation counseling briefing.
However, the Department, as noted in the GAO Report, recognizes there
are inconsistencies in the delivery of USERRA and VA Benefits Briefings
for the Guard and Reserves, and these inconsistencies vary from
installation to installation. In some instances units are being
deactivated at locations other than an Active Component installation
such as from a National Guard Armory. When this occurs, providing
transition service becomes problematic. In other cases, individuals may
be “falling through the cracks.” We believe such occurrences are rare
and isolated, but even one, is one too many.
DoD Partnership with DOL and VA
The full scope of TAP goes beyond what we in the Department offer our
separating Service members. As I just mentioned, TAP also includes
services and benefits available from the Departments of Labor and
Veterans Affairs. For that reason, the Department has enjoyed a
long-standing partnership with these agencies since the beginning of
TAP. Another challenge before us as it relates to the Guard and Reserve
is how and when do we provide timely transition services. Although
Preseparation Counseling does not appear to be a major issue during
demobilization, the Department is concerned that the time allotted for
Presepartion Counseling at many locations is insufficient; thus, the TAP
counselor is not able to provide a quality Preseparation Counseling
Briefing. The Department will continue to work with the Military
Departments down through the chain of command at demobilization sites to
standardize the time allotted for the delivery of the mandatory
Preseparation Counseling for the Guard and Reserve.
Mr. Chairman, from my review of the GAO Report, I believe the real areas
of concern for this Subcommittee center on employment assistance, VA
Benefits Briefings, and DTAP for the Guard and Reserve.
The Department of Labor’s 2 ½ day DOL TAP Employment Workshop is
appropriate for the Active Components. Given the assumption that the
overwhelming majority of our Guard and Reserve members have jobs when
activated and mobilized, the Department supports DOL’s USERRA briefings
as the most appropriate type of information that should be provided upon
demobilization. For those who were unemployed at the time of their
activation, the Department will work with DOL to consider other options,
such as a DOL employment workshop following demobilization. Potentially,
this could occur during one of the unit’s drill weekends. On the surface
this may seem to be a great solution; however, there are many issues
that have to be resolved before we go down that path. I will address
some of those issues later in my testimony. For both individuals who are
unemployed and those who want to consider career changes even though
they have a job to return to, I am confident DOL would refer them to a
One-Stop Career Center nearest to their hometown.
The final two components of TAP, the VA Benefits Briefing and DTAP, fall
under the same scenario as the DOL Employment Workshop. Since these
components are the responsibility of VA, I will defer to my
distinguished colleague from VA to discuss in more detail the
information and services they provide and ask them to share with the
Committee some of the challenges they will face if called upon to
provide these briefings after demobilization.
Focus of Hearing -- Guard and Reserve
Mr. Chairman, I am keenly aware that there is great concern by this
Committee as well as the entire Congress about the breadth and quality
of services and benefits being provided to our Guard and Reserve
personnel as they return home. DoD, the Military Services, DOL, and VA
are working diligently to ensure these brave men and women are not left
behind or left out.
The Military Services are making every effort to provide Preseparation
Counseling to all returning units at the demobilization sites. And, as
already noted, the Department will take the necessary steps to
standardize the time allotted to TAP counselors so they can provide the
quality Preseparation Counseling Briefings our Guard and Reserve
personnel deserve.
However, the reality is that our returning Guard and Reserve personnel
are only at their Demobilization station for a period of three to five
days. Given their high anxiety to return home to their families and
loved ones, the Department must carefully balance that desire with the
need to provide them with the kind of information they need and deserve.
The Department realizes that the demand for more time to get things done
at demobilization sites, although well intended, has probably exceeded
the capabilities of the demobilization process to meet those demands.
That is why the Department concurs with the recommendation for Executive
Action contained in GAO Report, GAO-05-544, entitled: “Military and
Veterans’ Benefits: Enhanced Services Could Improve Transition
Assistance for Reserves and National Guard. The recommendation states:
“To ensure that members of the Reserve and National Guard have the
opportunity to benefit from transition assistance, we recommend that DoD
in collaboration with DOL and VA, determine what demobilizing Reserve
and National Guard members need to make a smooth transition and explore
the logistical options for providing that assistance, such as
opportunities for employment workshops before or after their
demobilization and providing timely information about the need to apply
for certain benefits while still on active duty.”
To that end, the Deputy Under Secretary of Defense for Military
Community and Family Policy, Mr. John Molino, is taking the lead in
collaboration with our partners from DOL and VA to form a “Demobilizing
Working Group” whose focus will be assessing the needs of Guard and
Reserve Service members during demobilization. They will make
recommendations to the senior leadership of all Departments concerned,
on how we can collectively improve transition assistance in the
demobilization process for Reserves and the National Guard. The
“Demobilization Working Group” will work under the umbrella of our
existing Transition Assistance Program (TAP) Steering Committee, a
standing committee with representatives from DoD, the Military Services,
DOL, VA, and Department of Homeland Security that meets on a quarterly
basis and is chaired by the Department of Labor.
The “Demobilization Working Group” will also have representatives from
the Guard and Reserve, and the demobilization and personnel communities.
I mentioned earlier that I would address some of the issues that must be
dealt with before we proceed. You will also hear some of these same
themes repeated later in my remarks. Some of the issues and challenges
the “Demobilization Working Group” will tackle are:
• Assessing the needs of demobilizing Guard and Reserve Service members.
• Evaluating various logistical options for providing assistance.
• Assessing whether timely information about the need to apply for
certain benefits while still on active duty is being provided at all
demobilization/deactivation locations.
• Identifying gaps in the current system.
• Determining the right time to provide information.
• Determining how much it will cost and who will fund the program, if
information is provided after demobilization and during a drilling
weekend.
• Determining what the deactivation time line for scheduling briefings
will be -- 30 days, 60 days after demobilization – we just don’t know
right now.
• Deciding if spouses should be included in post deactivation briefings.
• Identifying the resources, needed to support the Guard and Reserve
transition requirements, whether before or after deactivation.
• Developing other options to address the needs and concerns of our
Guard and Reserve members.
As you can see, this is a complex and difficult issue before us, but not
one that is insurmountable.
In the interim, DOL and VA have assured DoD that, upon request by a
deactivated unit, they will fulfill such requests and provide TAP
Employment Workshops and VA briefings at unit locations. The Department
will continue to improve the process and the delivery of these services
to all our Service members and their families. That is the challenge for
TAP before the Department, the Military Services, DOL, and VA today.
DoD Initiatives
DoD has several initiatives under consideration that are designed to
address some of these issues. The focus of these initiatives is
improving transition assistance for both Active and Reserve Component
Service members. Let me cite just a few and enumerate on some of the
challenges associated with some of them.
First – The Department has a revised Directive on Transition Assistance
for Military Personnel out for coordination and comment. The key changes
in the Directive will:
• Incorporate the change in law that make Reserve Component Service
members serving 180 continuous days on active duty and their families
eligible for TAP. DoD is in compliance with the law but the language is
now being included in DoD policy.
• Mandate the availability for Active Component Service members
separating and retiring, who indicate they want to attend a DOL
Employment Workshop (and where there is no DOL presence, a Military
Service Employment Workshop) to attend these workshops in their
entirety. However, this mandate has two very important issues that must
be resolved:
o First – If this mandate is applied to the Guard and Reserves before
being released from active duty, during the demobilization process,
then, the Department has to be prepared to lengthen the current
demobilization timeline and expand the mandate to include the Reserve
Components. Or, the Department has to decide to apply the mandate to the
Guard and Reserve but authorize its compliance after demobilization,
during a drilling weekend. That leads to the second issue --
o Second, can DOL fully support this mandate for the Active and Reserve
Components?
• Mandate all Active Component separating and retiring Service members
attend a VA Benefits Briefing and those with a service-connected
disability, or those who think they have a service-connected disability,
attend DTAP. The same issues mentioned above relating to the DOL
Workshop, apply to this mandate and impact our partners at VA.
• Now, let me throw the final ingredient into the mix. These mandates
that the Department wants to implement, present even greater challenges
to DOL and VA for our Service members stationed overseas. They will have
the greatest impact on Active Component Service members stationed
overseas. Let me point out to the Subcommittee that we do conduct
demobilization for some, but not very many, Reserve Component members at
overseas locations. Let me briefly cite a couple of the challenges
confronting DOL and VA in providing DOL Employment Workshops, VA
Benefits Briefings and DTAP to separating and retiring Service members
overseas.
o First – There are Status of Forces Agreement (SOFA) issues that must
be resolved before DOL and VA can be authorized to operate in foreign
countries on a permanent basis at military installations where DoD and
the Military Services have a transition presence. This problem exists
today. DOL is working to resolve these issues country by country – but
it is a slow and difficult process.
o VA’s challenges are: 1) providing 12-month coverage overseas; 2)
getting SOFA authorization from each country where they need to operate
on a permanent basis; and 3) expanding their coverage to cover all
installations where DoD has a transition presence.
Second – The recent General Accounting Office Report “Military and
Veterans’ Benefits: Enhanced Services Could Improve Transition
Assistance for Reserves and National Guard” noted several actions
directed at improving program content. Developing a separate
“Preseparation Counseling Checklist” for members of the Reserve
Components was one initiative. The new form was approved effective June
15, 2005. The Military Services will move as quickly as possible to
implement the new form.
Third – The GAO report also noted that for full-time active duty Service
members, the Department had drafted an updated counseling checklist. The
updated “Preseparation Counseling Checklist” for active duty Service
members was also approved effective June 15, 2005. The updated form will
enhance program content and provide an improved Presepartion Counseling
Briefing. The Military Services will move as quickly as possible to
implement the updated form.
Fourth – The Department is staffing two Memorandums:
a. The subject of the first one is: Command Support – Transition
Assistance Program (TAP) for Active Component Service Members
b. The second memorandum’s subject is: Command Support – Transition
Assistance Program (TAP) for Demobilizing Reserve Component Service
Members. The intent of both memorandums is to reiterate the Department’s
commitment to TAP for both the Active and Reserve Component service
member.
The challenges that I lay before you by no means discourage us or deter
our commitment to move these policy mandates forward. We owe it to our
Service members to prepare them, to the extent possible, for their
return to civilian life.
Good News – VA and DOL
That being said, I would now like to turn your attention to and share
with you some of the good news on things taking place among DoD, DOL,
and VA.
DoD is working with VA through a number of collaborative efforts such as
the Benefits Executive Council, the Health Executive Council, the Joint
Executive Council, and Seamless Transition.
VA is working closely with the Military Services at the major
demobilization sites to ensure that VA representatives are part of the
briefings provided to returning Service members. VA continues to place a
major focus on Service members being separated or discharged for medical
reasons. They have placed Veterans Service Representatives and Social
Workers at key military installation medical treatment facilities where
severely wounded Service members from Iraq and Afghanistan are
frequently sent. They include Walter Reed Army Medical Center, National
Naval Medical Center-Bethesda, Eisenhower Army Medical Center, Brook
Army Medical Center and Madigan Army Medical Center.
Our work with the Department of Labor includes the DoD-DOL Policy
Steering Group – a collaborative effort that deals with Recruitment,
Retention, and Re-Entry issues for Military Personnel and their spouses;
and, as I have already mentioned, the TAP Steering Committee. In
addition, under Secretary Chao’s Recovery and Employment Assistance
Lifelines Initiative, commonly referred to as REALifelines, DOL has
placed personnel at Walter Reed Army Medical Center and the National
Naval Medical Center-Bethesda. Because of the success of this initiative
they are expanding REALifelines to Madigan Army Medical Center and
Brooke Army Medical Center. REALifelines is a new approach to ensure
that wounded and injured Service members and their families get the
support they need to be successful and competitive as they return to the
homes and lives they left in service to our country and the cause of
freedom.
DOL is also working with several States conducting pilot programs to
provide employment assistance services to our returning Guard and
Reserve personnel.
And just before his departure from DOL, the former Assistant Secretary
of Labor for Veterans Employment and Training Service, the Honorable
Frederico Juarbe, Jr. sent a letter to the Department’s Deputy Under
Secretary of Defense for Military Community and Family Policy in
anticipation of the report by the GAO, which is the basis for this
Hearing today. In his letter, former Secretary Juarbe told Mr. Molino
that one of his last acts before leaving DOL was to initiate contact
with The Adjutant General of each state in an effort to determine their
needs. He asked for the Department’s assistance to help notify the
Chiefs of the various components of the Armed Forces Reserves about the
employment assistance programs offered by DOL VETS.
Mr. Chairman, I don’t want to take all of the thunder from my
distinguished colleagues from VA and DOL, so let me stop here. I am sure
they are anxious to tell you first hand about their initiatives for
providing TAP and DTAP services to our Guard and Reserve members.
Our Service members have, and continue to perform, magnificently while
enduring many hardships since 9-11, in support of Homeland Security,
Iraqi Freedom, and Enduring Freedom. For their unselfish and loyal
service to this great Nation, and on the behalf of the President and the
Secretary of Defense, I want to thank them for their devotion, loyalty
and esprit de corps while facing the enemy at home and abroad.
The Department remains steadfast in its commitment to offer separating
Service members, retirees, Guard and Reserve personnel, and their
families a quality Transition Assistance Program well into the future.
WHY? One might ask; “because it’s right; because it’s smart.”
In conclusion Mr. Chairman, on behalf of our Service members and their
families, thank you and the members of this Subcommittee for your
support during these demanding times. I stand ready to answer your
questions.
|