Statement of
Gold Star Wives of America, Inc.
before the
Committee on Veterans’ Affairs
United States House of Representatives
February 16, 2006
Presented by
Mrs. Rose Elizabeth Lee
Gold Star Wives of America, Inc.
Chair, Legislative Committee
“With malice toward none; with charity for
all; with firmness in the right, as God gives us to see right, let us
strive to finish the work we are in; to bind up the nation’s wounds, to
care for him who has borne the battle, his widow and his orphan.”
…President Abraham Lincoln, Second Inaugural Address, March 4, 1865
INTRODUCTION/BACKGROUND
Mr. Chairman, Representative Evans, and Members of the House Veterans’
Affairs Committee, I would like to thank you for the opportunity to
testify before you today on behalf of all Gold Star Wives regarding the
importance of addressing critical services for America's military widows
and their children.
My name is Rose Lee. I am a widow and I am here before you as the Chair
of the Gold Star Wives (GSW) Committee on Legislation. I am also
currently President of the Potomac Area Chapter. In the past, I have
held the positions of National President and Chair, Board of Directors
for GSW. For many years now I have been working to achieve the overall
goals of the Gold Star Wives, and more specifically to assist our young,
new widows, one by one, wind their way through the maze that lies before
them with first notification of the death of their loved one.
The Gold Star Wives of America, Inc. was founded in 1945 and is a
Congressionally-chartered service organization comprised of surviving
spouses of military service members who died while on active duty or as
a result of a service-connected disability. We could begin with no
better advocate than Mrs. Eleanor Roosevelt, newly widowed, who helped
make GSW a truly national organization. Mrs. Roosevelt was an original
signer of our Certificate of Incorporation as a member of the Board of
Directors. Many of our current membership of over 10,000 are the widows
of service members who were killed in combat during World War II, the
Korean War, the Vietnam War and the more recent wars including the one
we are currently in, the Global War On Terrorism (GWOT).
In my testimony I will respond to your request for our legislative views
on the past year, an assessment of the present, and a look ahead into
2008. In doing so, I will present to you the collective goals of the
Gold Star Wives with the hopes that they will alert you to certain
discrepancies and inefficiencies that you may be able to alleviate in
your deliberations this year.
I do want to thank the Members of this committee and the staff for your
continued support of programs that directly support the well-being of
our service members’ widows and their families. It is imperative that
the difficulty of the sacrifice of our husbands’ lives should not be
compounded by lack of information, confusing information and sometimes
even erroneous information that prevent our widows from accessing the
assistance she needs to begin the rest of her life without that core
person who had been her most critical support.
THE CHALLENGE
We are unmistakably in a time of war. Warriors are dying and leaving
behind young families. If there is one message I could leave you with
today it is that there is never enough good communication. The Casualty
Assistance Calls Officers (CACOs) have a difficult mission in a
difficult time. They act to assist survivors from the death notification
to assistance with coordinating funeral arrangements to applying for
benefits and entitlements. They do a valiant job but CACOs are not
trained to be the subject matter expert for the benefits and
entitlements managed by the VA or the DoD.
Our widows need our help. We need to identify and reach out to them. In
addition, we must coordinate with our counterparts in other agencies to
ensure that the message given is thorough and consistent as they
transition to their lives made forever different by the loss of a loved
one.
We need to examine the coordination process between agencies more
closely and work hard to prevent these widows and their children from
encountering gaps in identifying benefits.
GOVERNMENT INITIATIVES
The Departments of Veterans Affairs (VA) and Defense (DoD), including
the Military Services, have several on-going programs which merit
attention as critical facets in serving widows in this most difficult
time of their lives. These organizations together have co-hosted a
series of meetings that focus on improving outreach to surviving family
members. VA in collaboration with DoD and the Social Security
Administration has created a Survivors Web Site that offers
communication channels for all services widows and widowers who are
entitled to and need to continue their daily living. Often widows do not
even know where to turn simply to identify their benefits. We
participate in this outreach and applaud these efforts. To enhance these
efforts, GSW asks your serious consideration of creating an oversight
office for survivors across the VA and DoD to assure improved delivery
of benefit information and benefits to survivors.
BRIDGING THE GAPS
Getting the right information to the right people at the right time is
important. Getting the right benefit is important as well. There are
gaps in the benefit for survivors that we have called for corrective
action on over time. Most will not be new to you. It is time to act.
1. Despite valiant efforts over the past year, the dollar for dollar
offset of Survivor Benefit Plan (SBP) annuity payments by benefits from
the VA’s Dependency and Indemnity Compensation program was NOT
eliminated. The SBP was meant to provide income protection for
survivors. This income is not protected when the DIC benefit offsets the
SBP income to which a survivor is entitled, sometimes eliminating the
entire SBP. We recognize you must act with your colleagues on the
Committee on Armed Services on this issue. We thank Rep. Henry Brown for
introducing HR 808 and encourage Congress to provide this real relief
for our military surviving spouses now.
2. The law currently allows for surviving spouses who remarry after age
57 to retain their VA DIC survivor benefit. For those who remarried
before that law was enacted, there was a one-year period to apply for
reinstatement. Communication in the form of outreach was lacking during
the retroactive period. Therefore, we thank Rep. Michael Bilirakis for
introducing H.R. 1462, which will make two equitable changes to the law:
a. allow survivors to retain DIC on remarriage at age 55 in order to
bring this benefit in line with rules for SBP and other federal survivor
programs; and
b. open up the reinstatement period with renewed outreach efforts to
make survivors aware of their eligibility.
3. There are inequities among several payments for the child survivor
that need immediate attention. The SBP child option applies now only to
survivors of deaths after November 24, 2003. We seek this benefit to be
linked to October 7, 2001, the beginning of the Global War on Terror as
are other survivor benefits. Similarly, the additional monthly $250
child DIC payment per family only applies to survivors of deaths after
January 1, 2005. This too should be linked to October 7, 2001. We thank
Rep. Michael Michaud for introducing HR 1573 which provided for this
additional payment to families. It makes no sense that the survivors of
those who died ‘first’ should be prohibited from accessing a benefit
given to survivors of those who died later in the same war. There’s
another grievous oversight concerning the $250 child DIC. The program
evaluation of benefits study recommended that surviving spouses with
dependent children receive the $250 for FIVE years instead of TWO years
this is currently provided and that amount should be indexed for
inflation, to avoid a devaluation of the benefit. Unfortunately, those
recommendations were ignored. I want to note that the $250 child DIC is
the only DIC benefit that doesn’t receive the Cost of Living Adjustment
(COLA). However, we wish to thank those of you who tried to include a
COLA in legislation for the $250 child DIC.
4. CHAMPVA, the Civilian Health and Medical Program of the Department of
Veterans’ Affairs, currently does not carry with it a dental plan. In
order to increase beneficiaries’ access to dental care at a reasonable
cost, GSW seeks for widows and all CHAMPVA beneficiaries the ability to
purchase a voluntary dental insurance plan. We are in agreement that the
model of the TRICARE program for military service retirees for dental
care in which the payment of premiums or services is completely funded
by the enrollee is an acceptable model. Beneficiaries are simply looking
for affordable dental care, which can be accomplished through a group
plan. Allowing for assignment of VA benefits to cover the cost of dental
insurance premiums would be an additional benefit to ease the payment
process. This would require a modification to Title 38, Chapter 53.
5. We would like to begin the process of reviewing how the DIC rate is
established, which is currently a flat rate of $1,033. The SBP is
calculated at 55 percent of retired pay, as if the member had retired
for total disability on the date of death. We recommend that the DIC be
calculated in a similar manner at 55 percent of the disabled veterans
100 percent disability compensation amount. We recognize there are
complexities in this depending on rank of the deceased and on date of
death, but we do believe this would help alleviate growing financial
difficulties of widows from wars prior to this conflict who are
receiving only DIC. We would welcome the opportunity to work with the
committee in determining how to implement these changes, which will
provide more equitable compensation to our survivors.
Finally, there are three other issues that we want to bring to your
attention:
1. Widows whose husband died in VA hospitals due to wrongful VA hospital
care receive only DIC without any other VA benefits (Title 38 USC 1151).
We urge the Committee to support the measures necessary to allow these
widows to be entitled to the CHAMPVA benefit also. These wrongful deaths
are not much different than those killed by friendly fire.
2. We recommend that the Committee ensure that medical benefits be
provided fairly and equitably include surviving spouses and eligible
children (i.e., seek legislation to remove Part B penalties and interest
for late enrollment and promote a feasibility study to convert VA
facilities to Long Term Care facilities which would welcome
widows/widowers).
3. Education benefits for surviving spouses who are on active duty
should be able to use the education benefit derived from her deceased
husband while still serving on active duty. Currently, the active duty
widow must resign from the military in order to use the derived
educational benefit. GSWs urges this Committee to review and change this
law.
CONCLUSION
In conclusion, we do not want our widows to be forgotten whether they
are experiencing their losses in the Global War on Terror over the past
five years or whether they are members of the so-called Greatest
Generation and experienced their loss many years ago during World War
II. Whenever the ultimate sacrifice is given, there is family left
behind. In the same way we have asked some to give their lives, we have
also asked some to continue their lives with a chasm so large it is
difficult to transgress. Let us show the spirit of this nation by not
forgetting these widows, whose numbers grow daily.
I thank this Committee for using this hearing as one more avenue of
awareness and education and for giving me an opportunity to share my
thoughts and the goals of the Gold Star Wives. We will be happy to work
with the committee on any of these initiatives. Thank you.
BIOGRAPHY
MRS. ROSE ELIZABETH LEE
Rose Lee was born in Pittsburg, California and is the widow of Colonel
C. M. Lee, U.S. Army, who served in Korea and in Vietnam. He died on
active duty overseas in 1972. Rose has two children and three
grandchildren. In 1978, she was appointed Gold Star Wives Washington
Representative and has been active through most of the time since then.
Rose was Gold Star Wives National President 1991 – 1993 and Chair of the
Board of Directors 1998 – 2002. She is currently the Potomac Area
Chapter President since 2004. All her Gold Star Wives work is voluntary.
Her mission is to “train” new young widows to become involved with
legislative work. She is also an appointed member of the VA Advisory
Committee on Cemeteries and Memorials.
Rose worked in personnel management, Veterans’ Employment, and retired
from Federal service in 1992. Rose appreciates her VA Education Benefits
as she used them to return to school to complete a BA in Political
Science and a Master of Public Administration in 1977 from the American
University, Washington, D.C.
DISCLOSURE STATEMENT
Neither Mrs. Lee nor the Gold Star Wives of America, Inc. have received
any Federal grant or contract, relevant to the subject matter of this
testimony, during the current or previous two fiscal years.
_____________________________ ___________________
Signature, Mrs. Rose E. Lee Date
|