Statement of
Frances M. Murphy, M.D.,
Deputy Under Secretary for Health Policy Coordination
Department of Veterans Affairs
November 19, 2003
Mr. Chairman and Members of the Committee,
I am pleased to appear before you today to give testimony regarding the
progress being made by the Department of Defense (DoD) and the
Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) to share health information and to
develop a veteran-centric, seamless electronic health record.
One of the most important lessons learned from the 1st Gulf War is the
need for interagency collaboration on deployment health issues, and the
need for health data regarding a service member’s deployment,
occupational exposures and health conditions that will allow VA to
provide the best possible health care and benefits for veterans. VA
applauds the efforts of DoD to prevent health problems among deployed
troops. Furthermore DoD is providing cutting edge care in-theater for
combat casualties. However, the wounds of war are not always obvious,
and we appreciate today that military service may have enduring health
consequences long after the actual war has ended.
Improved medical record keeping and data from environmental surveillance
during deployments can be invaluable for addressing the short and
long-term health care and benefits needs of America’s veterans. In the
short-term, VA needs information that may be relevant to recently
deployed service members’ or veterans’ immediate health care needs,
looking for any unusual health problems among newly separated veterans
from a specific deployment, and to establish special health care
eligibility for returning combat theatre veterans. In the long term, VA
needs clinical and administrative data to evaluate the long-term health
of veterans from a specific deployment – to be able to answer key
questions and concerns from veterans and their families about important
matters like reproductive health issues or cancer rates among veterans
in comparison with their non-deployed peers.
To this end, the “President’s Taskforce to Improve Health Care Delivery
For Our Nation’s Veterans” (PTF) focused upon the importance of
providing for a seamless transition from military to veteran status,
including the coordination and sharing of electronic health information
between VA and DoD. VA is working with DoD through the VA/DoD Health
Executive Council and Joint Executive Council and in other venues to
keep the focus upon this critical goal of information sharing.
Create a Seamless Transition
The President’s Task Force recommended that the two departments use
standardized electronic health-related information nationwide to help
ensure a seamless transition from military to veteran status. As the
Task Force has noted, information systems coordination is a critical
link between the two Departments.
DoD and VA are moving forward jointly to improve the efficiency and
accuracy of enrollment information through the creation of integration
points that will permit VA to access the Defense Enrollment and
Eligibility Reporting System (DEERS) in real time by the end of 2005, a
key objective in the President’s Management Agenda. The Veterans Health
Administration (VHA) has identified a need for service indicators (such
as contingency locations and dates of service, receipt of imminent
danger and hazardous duty pay, etc) from DoD that will support VA’s
delivery of special health care benefits to Combat Veterans. As this
information sharing becomes a reality, we expect that a service member’s
transition from active duty to veteran status will be simplified
significantly while improving the process of accurately informing the
veteran of all potential benefits for which s/he may be eligible.
Another key information technology initiative in the President’s
Management Agenda addresses the sharing of individual health care
information between the two systems. We believe that VA and DoD are
making progress towards deployment of electronic medical records that
are interoperable, bi-directional, and standards-based by the end of
2005. Our Departments have formed a close collaborative partnership, to
include the development of a joint business case for electronic health
records, under the Federal Health Information Exchange (FHIE) and
HealthePeople (Federal) projects. In addition, we have signed formal
Memoranda of Understanding on development of additional joint activities
under both FHIE and HealthePeople (Federal).
As a result of the implementation of FHIE, VA clinical staff have access
to information that was collected in DoD's Composite Health Care System
(CHCS) on veterans who have been discharged since that system was
implemented in 1989. Information available up to the time of their
separation includes laboratory results, radiology reports, outpatient
pharmacy prescription information, admission/disposition/transfer
records, discharge summaries, and in the near future information on
allergies, consult reports, and summary outpatient appointment
information. The Veterans Benefit Administration (VBA) staff use this
information to fulfill the evidentiary requirements for processing
disability compensation claims as well as in determining eligibility for
Vocational Rehabilitation and Employment benefits.
The joint VA/DoD Interoperable Electronic Health Record Plan (HealthePeople
(Federal)) goes much further by committing our two Departments to
implementing compatible IT enterprise architectures and adopting common
standards, both of which serve as the essential technical foundation to
achieve interoperable electronic health record systems. The end result
will be interoperable electronic health record systems that will serve
the needs of our nation’s veterans and service members and that could
potentially serve as a model for a national health information
infrastructure.
Mr. Chairman, we testified before the subcommittee on July 9, 2003 and
before the full committee on October 16, 2003 on current efforts to
assure a seamless transition for veterans returning from Operations
Iraqi Freedom and Enduring Freedom. I would first like to update the
committee on the efforts of our Seamless Transition Taskforce and then
discuss our plan and progress toward improving electronic transmission
of health information.
Seamless Transition Taskforce
In August of this year, VA’s Under Secretary for Benefits and the Under
Secretary for Health charged a new VA Taskforce for the Seamless
Transition of Returning Service Members to intensify and continue
efforts to assure world class services are provided to our military and
veterans. This taskforce focused initially on internal coordination,
communication and staff training efforts to ensure that VA approaches
this mission in a comprehensive manner. Also, efforts are targeted on
improving dialogue and collaboration with DoD at all levels between our
two Departments, including the Military Services, Personnel and
Readiness, Health Affairs, and Reserve Affairs. We have been working
closely with DoD to enhance our ability to identify and serve all
returning service members that sustained injuries or illnesses while
serving our country.
Thanks to the leadership of Dr. David Chu and Dr. Bill Winkenwerder, I
am pleased to report that DoD transferred to VHA a list of military
personnel who recently served in theaters of combat in Afghanistan and
Iraq and subsequently separated from active duty. Our records indicate
that of the approximate 17,000 veterans on this initial list, as of
September 30, 2003, about 2,000 (12%) had sought health care from VA for
a wide variety of health problems. Of this group, most have been seen as
outpatients. VA looks forward to timely updates of this list and to the
sharing of a complete roster of deployed troops, as was provided after
the Gulf war in 1991. With a complete roster, VA can ensure that combat
veterans receive new health care benefits and that emerging health
problems are rapidly identified. VA also looks forward to receiving DoD
pre- and post-deployment screening data, which will assist VA in the
clinical evaluation of returning war veterans.
To ensure that our commitment is understood and shared at every level of
the Department of Veterans Affairs, the Seamless Transition Taskforce
has developed training materials for staff including a script and video
for front line staff to ensure that they can reliably identify veterans
who have served in a theater of combat operations and take the steps
necessary to ensure they receive appropriate care. A software package
was recently released to identify these combat veterans and a video for
staff training has been finalized and will be provided to every VHA and
VBA field site.
As discussed during the October 16 full Committee hearing, we have taken
a number of additional steps including assignment of points of contact
at each facility; issuance of case management guidance; assignment of VA
staff to Military Treatment Facilities to provide information and
assistance concerning VA benefits and to arrange for transfer of
patients to VA health care facilities; and expanded outreach efforts to
assure a seamless transition. We are working to expand these efforts and
have partnered with the Army Disabled Solder Liaison Team. An MOU is
being worked on which will help to standardize information transfer
processes to sustain our progress.
Mr. Chairman, we testified before the Oversight and Investigations
Subcommittee in early July of this year on the long - term outreach
strategies that VA is pursuing to assure the best possible care is
provided to returning Iraqi Freedom and Afghanistan Enduring Freedom
service members. Many of these efforts are coordinated with DoD under
the umbrella of the Health Executive Council.
All health or exposure data that DoD collects during deployment will be
useful to VA. Through the Deployment Health Work Group, we are actively
engaged with DoD in obtaining as much deployment health and exposure
information as is available. Members of the Work Group are also charged
with reviewing eventual sharing of data on troop locations, deployment
health risks, and pre- and post-deployment health screening. Further, we
are actively working with DoD to develop separation physical
examinations that thoroughly document a veteran’s health status at the
time of separation from military service and that also meet the
requirements of the physical examination needed by VA in connection with
a veteran’s claim for compensation benefits. We are optimistic that as a
result of the improved collaboration between VA and DoD in these
programs, we will be better positioned to evaluate health problems among
service members and veterans after they leave military service, to
address short and long-term post-deployment health questions, and to
document any changes in health status that may be relevant for
determining disability.
VA understands that veterans and their families will have questions and
concerns about any special health problems that may be associated with a
particular deployment, including infectious diseases and other
deployment hazards. To respond to those concerns, VHA has produced and
widely distributed a brochure addressing the main health concerns for
military service in Iraq today, and a similar brochure for veterans
serving in Afghanistan. Recently VHA distributed another brochure on
health care for women veterans returning from the Gulf region. These
brochures answer health-related questions that veterans, their families,
and health care providers may have about these hazardous military
deployments. They also describe relevant medical care programs that VA
has developed in anticipation of the health needs of veterans returning
from combat and peacekeeping missions abroad. These are also widely
distributed to military contacts, veterans service representatives and
are on VA’s website.
Other Long-Term Strategies
Since the 1991 Gulf War, VA has developed a broad array of programs and
policies to assist veterans returning from combat missions abroad. These
were discussed during the subcommittee’s July 9, 2003 hearing and the
full committee’s October 16, 2003 hearings. Two initiatives are
particularly important to assuring recognition of service related health
problems:
• Implementation of a screening instrument in the form of a clinical
reminder triggered by the veteran's separation date to assist our health
care providers to properly identify and treat returning Iraqi Freedom
and Afghanistan veterans that present for care in VA. This assessment
tool will prompt the provider with specific data requirements to assure
that veterans are screened for medical and psychological conditions that
may be related to recent combat deployment. This clinical reminder is in
final pilot testing at several VAMCs.
• VA has developed evidence based clinical approaches for treating
veterans following hazardous deployments. These clinical practice
guidelines (CPGs) give health care providers the needed structure,
clinical tools, and educational resources that allow them to diagnose
and manage patients with deployment-related health concerns. Two
post-deployment CPGs have been developed in collaboration with DoD, a
general purpose post-deployment CPG and a CPG for chronic fatigue and
pain. These CPGs will substantially aid VA and DoD efforts to care for
veterans with unexplained illnesses, which are found among veterans
following all wars.
• VA and DoD will soon release a new CPG on the management of traumatic
stress. This guideline pools DoD and VA expertise to help build a joint
assessment and treatment infrastructure between the two systems in order
to coordinate primary care and mental health care for the purpose of
managing, and, if possible, preventing acute and chronic Post Traumatic
Stress Disorder (PTSD).
The Electronic Health Record Systems Plan – HealthePeople (Federal)
Having documented many lessons from treating returning veterans after
the 1991 Gulf War, VA implemented a number of initiatives to better
support sharing medical information with DoD. In addition, it became
quite evident that the Departments needed a workable strategy whereby
they could effectively transmit health information between Departments
for the purpose of providing high-quality, effective, safe healthcare
for beneficiaries of both Departments. Also, the electronic transfer of
medical information will improve the quality of care to the over 700,000
individuals who receive care from both DoD and VA annually.
During this past year the Departments developed and received approval
for a strategy to achieve interoperability of health information systems
for the purpose of sharing health data. The plan documents the roadmap
for VA and DoD to demonstrate interoperability in 2004 and to achieve
initial interoperability between health information systems in DoD and
VA by 2005. The plan provides for the exchange of health data by the
Departments and development of a health information infrastructure and
architecture supported by common data, communications, security and
software standards and high performance health information systems.
The Joint Plan will support HealthePeople (Federal), a long-term
strategy to achieve full interoperability among Federal health
information systems starting with the ability to provide a two-way
exchange of health related information between VA and DoD. Providers of
care in both Departments will be able to access relevant medical
information to aid them in patient care. HealthePeople (Federal) was
initiated to:
• Improve sharing of information
• Adopt common standards for architecture, security, communications,
data, technology, and software
• Seek joint procurements and/or building of applications where
appropriate
• Seek opportunities for sharing existing systems and technology
• Explore convergence of VA and DoD health information technology
applications where feasible and within mission requirements
• Develop interoperable health records and data repositories
The standards and processes developed in this VA – DoD initiative will
be beneficial to the private sector effort to transmit medical
information electronically. Full interoperability is dependent upon both
Departments deploying their next-generation health information systems,
the DoD Composite Healthcare System II (CHCS II) and the VA
HealtheVet-VistA system.
Plan Initiatives
There are several major initiatives that form the Electronic Health
Record Systems Plan – HealthePeople (Federal). The Departments are
presently collaborating on the development of interoperable data
repositories that will form the backbone for all sharing of electronic
health information; joint or interoperable software applications; and
the adoption and identification of common data, architecture,
communications, security and software standards.
The backbone of the Electronic Health Records Plan is the co-development
and acquisition of interoperable data repositories by the Departments.
By linking the DoD Clinical Data Repository (CDR) to the VA Health Data
Repository (HDR), the Departments will achieve full interoperability of
health information between DoD's CHCS II and VA's HealtheVet-VistA.
Using clinical decision support applications, providers of care in both
Departments will be able to access and use the relevant health
information to aid them in making medication decisions for their
patients regardless of whether that information resides in VA's or DoD's
information systems.
The Departments are on track to demonstrate bi-directional health
information using interoperable data repositories beginning with
pharmacy data this fiscal year. VA and DoD have formed an active working
integrated product team to lead this effort and development efforts are
underway to deploy a working prototype in a lab environment.
Collaborative Software Applications
Since June 2002, phase I of the Electronic Health Record Systems Plan,
the Federal Health Information Exchange (FHIE) (Its predecessor was the
government computer based patient record (GCPR)) has provided all
medical centers the capability to access historical data on separated
and retired military personnel from the DoD’s Composite Health Care
System (CHCS I). Current patient data that are being sent from DoD to VA
via secure messaging include laboratory results, radiology reports,
outpatient pharmacy information, patient demographics, admission
discharge transfer (ADT) data, discharge summaries and allergies. This
includes (a) providing such information at the time of the service
member’s separation from military service, and (b) gathering and
transmitting, under a set schedule, the same protected electronic health
information on previously separated veterans. The original requirements
for FHIE were revised to make them HIPAA compliant. The current phase of
FHIE work continues in operational status and adds three more data
categories as part of the enhancement work or planned product
improvements. All of the initial requirements for FHIE have now been met
through the implementation of Version 4 in September 2003. Additional
capabilities have been added to the original project to transmit data
from the DoD Pharmacy Data Transaction Service (PDTS) and the DoD
Standard Ambulatory Data Record (SADR).
Beyond FHIE and as part of the joint plan, VA is working closely with
DoD to jointly develop or acquire other software applications that will
support the delivery of health care by enabling the sharing of health
information. The Departments have made significant progress toward
development of interoperable software applications to include
credentialing, scheduling laboratory and electronic portal systems for
beneficiaries. The Departments are presently enhancing the Laboratory
Data Sharing and Interoperability software application to permit
bi-directional support of lab requests and results between VA and DoD
reference labs.
Additional VA Work on the Electronic Health Record
A significant, supportive component of our better serving veterans is
VA’s new web application, “My HealtheVet”. My HealtheVet creates an
Internet environment where veterans, family, and clinicians may come
together to optimize veterans’ health care. An early release of this
application on Veterans Day 2003 provides powerful health education
information and health self-assessment tools. In the future, veterans
will be able to reorder medications, view appointments and review copies
of their health records online. In addition, My HealtheVet will allow
each Veteran to share important military service history that can be
utilized for evaluating health and disability status with the veteran’s
permission. Nationwide implementation will occur through three phases,
each with increasingly complex functionality and security. Project
implementation is targeted for completion by October 2005. VA is closely
working with DoD on its portal application, TRICARE Online. The
Departments presently share the same health and wellness content and are
exploring additional collaboration.
VA/DoD Medical Demonstration Sites
The FY 2003 Defense Authorization Act mandated eight medical sites for
joint demonstrations between VA and DoD medical facilities. VA and DoD
recently announced the demonstration sites – three of which are pilot
efforts to enhance medical information and information technology
systems sharing between the two systems:
• Madigan Army Medical Center and Puget Sound VA Health Care System are
to be part of the piloting for a joint VA/DoD Electronic Health Record
Systems Interoperability Plan;
• El Paso VA Health Care System and William Beaumont Army Medical System
will conduct a Laboratory Data Sharing Initiative (LDSI); and
• South Texas Veterans Health Care System and Wilford Hall Medical
Center and Brooke Army Medical Center will develop and test a Laboratory
Data Sharing Initiative (LDSI) and test an integrated credentialing
system.
These demonstration projects will run through FY 2007.
Summary
A service member separating from military service and seeking health
care through VA today will have the benefit of VA’s more than
decade-long experience with Gulf War health issues as well as the
President’s commitment to improving VA/DoD collaboration. VA has
successfully adapted many existing programs, and created new programs as
necessary, that have improved outreach, improved clinical care through
practice guidelines and educational efforts, and improved VA health
providers access to DoD medical records. VA is actively working with DoD
to attain the maximum level of sharing of information on injured combat
veterans and recently discharged veterans. As a first step in creating a
lifelong electronic health record for veterans, VA and DoD have
developed a plan to share available electronic medical records by FY
2005.
A key component of optimal health care and assistance will be the
development with DoD of a veteran-centric, life-long health record.
Because this record has to begin at the start of military service, VA
has been actively engaged with DoD in the development of the Recruit
Assessment Program (RAP), which will collect comprehensive health data
from all service personnel at entry into the military. A life-long
health record will then be updated with clinical and exposure data
during military service, pre- and post-deployment health screening data,
discharge health data, and then clinical data from health care within
VA. This information will enable VA to provide the best health care
possible for our Nation’s veterans.
I note finally that the collection and sharing of medical information by
and between the Departments of Veterans Affairs and Defense is subject
to all privacy safeguards afforded by the Privacy Act of 1974 and the
Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996.
This concludes my statement. My colleague and I will be happy to respond
to any questions that you or other members of the Subcommittee might
have.
|